• download
  • Print
  • Recommend
  • 11

How to Market in a Downturn

Tags: Brand, Recession, Luxury, Branding, Marketing, John Quelch, Recession Marketing, Luxury Marketing, BNET Q&A, Discounting, Simplifiers, Customers, Ann Marsh

One of the best-known academic minds in marketing is John Quelch, a 30-year veteran of Harvard Business School and one of 10 marketing experts profiled in the 2007 book Conversations With Marketing Masters, by Laura Mazur and Louella Miles. Quelch’s own co-authored book, Greater Good: How Good Marketing Makes for Better Democracy, points out that marketing serves a higher purpose in society than simply moving products. Quelch writes the Marketing KnowHow blog for Harvard Business. Here he talks to BNET about the two types of luxury consumers and how to hang onto them in a recession.

You’ve said there are two types of luxury consumers. What are they?

I divide the luxury market into “must-haves” and “wannabes.” Members of the first group have incorporated luxury into their lives and seek to retain that lifestyle in the face of recession. Very high net worth individuals occupy the top rung of the must-haves. They are largely inoculated from the downturn. Even if they’ve lost a lot of money in the recession, they are still ultrarich. On the other hand, those must-haves who have become financially strapped are now buying luxury items at lower price points or buying them less often, but never compromising on quality.

The luxury wannabes view luxury aspirationally, occasionally investing in luxury purchases in order to touch luxury without immersing themselves in it. They would never buy (or probably would never be able to buy) a Ralph Lauren suit. But they can afford a few lower-cost accessories such as a polo shirt with the logo.

How do marketers hold on to these customers in this economy?

You have to figure out how your customers’ behavior has shifted. Can you enable your more price-sensitive customers to continue to patronize you? It’s a balancing act, because you don’t want to taint the image of the brand.

This is more challenging at a time when cash-strapped companies are reducing spending on market research that could help them learn just how to reach those customers. Most large companies in the U.S. are cutting their research budgets by 10 percent to 20 percent. To adjust to this shift, I urge marketers to focus their research on the products, brand, and markets that are key to their strategy. Don’t waste resources on peripheral or potential consumers.

Should you consider discounting? Or is that always a bad idea for luxury brands?

Of course, discounts, if overdone, can detract from brand quality and the credibility of retail list prices. But modest, often unadvertised discounts on selected or discontinued items need not dilute brand quality. In fact, during a recession, even some luxury must-haves are hurting and need a helping hand in the form of a price cut from their favored brands.

You’ve described a new kind of consumer as being a “Simplifier.” What does that mean?

Simplifiers predated the recession, but the recession has accelerated the trend. These are people who trade down to a simpler lifestyle than they are able to afford. In particular, they seek to reduce the scope and scale of the stuff they own, because they simply find it too aggravating to maintain and less emotionally satisfying than they expected. Often, as they grow older, they place more value on — and invest more money in — experiences instead of possessions.

Savvy marketers will keep this new Simplifier in mind when creating an argument for their product or service.

More on BNET:

 
Reply to Story

BNET TalkbackShare your ideas and expertise on this topic

Subscribe to this discussion via Email or RSS

  •  
    1

    chleoku@...

    07/21/09 | Report as spam

    RE: How to Market in a Downturn

    Very good artcle, especially for lots of marketing out there concern what to do in recessions. Keep in mind that the cusomer behaviours are starting to change to a more savings oriented mindset after the credit crunch:

    http://www.wealthalchemist.com/Blog/2009/06/dr-doom-speaks-global-economic-recovery-weak-late/

    Red the above for more details.

  •  
    2

    ladylux

    07/21/09 | Report as spam

    RE: How to Market in a Downturn

    Excellent article, and very relevant in these times. Certain behaviors, like clipping coupons on the lower-end side of the market, and buying higher-end discontinued items via unadvertised sales (as described above), are becoming more accepted. Smart style is back in favor, as well as eco-sustainable practices such as supporting "green" products and conserving natural products.

    However, it's important to keep your consumer segments separate, and deliver different goods at different price points via different retail outlets. For example, check out what household fashion name Max Azria is developing for WalMart: http://www.ladylux.com/style/site/article/miley_cyrus_max_azria_partner_for_walmart

  •  
    3

    anurodh_sharma1@...

    07/21/09 | Report as spam

    RE: How to Market in a Downturn

    Recession & high valued/luxery item sale is bound to have some knock down effect. I liked your Simplifiers concept who believe more in experiences than in possessions. I feel this has a lot of similarity to shift from industrial revolution to information revolution. This also explains the shift of manufacturing from developed economies to developing economies in the world.

  •  
    4

    jad67

    07/21/09 | Report as spam

    RE: How to Market in a Downturn

    Excellent article?
    When times are tight, retailers discount, and people are less prepared to spend?
    Well I'll be...
    As an oldie in business, I'd long suspected that much marketing discussion, like sociology, was about expressing simple concepts in complex terms, and this hasn't changed my mind.

  •  
    5

    business31

    07/22/09 | Report as spam

    Agree with jad67

    Where's the nugget here?

  •  
    6

    Joy B

    07/22/09 | Report as spam

    RE: How to Market in a Downturn

    Like Quelch's "must-have" and "wannabe" customer
    dichotomy. Fahrenheit 212 looks at luxury brands along
    similar lines: Absolute and Prestige brands. We think
    luxury companies need to re-ink the boundaries between
    these two distinct businesses, and innovate from within
    them.

    The nugget: Narrow and deep is the new black.

    For more please check out "Luxury's 2010 Innovation
    Collection" here:
    http://tinyurl.com/lzmg66

  •  
    7

    Jerryreborn

    07/23/09 | Report as spam

    RE: How to Market in a Downturn

    I?m happy to say that as ?Simplifier?, I buy clothes from chain-stores, wine from the supermarket, and mostly use public transport or walk. I?ll pay what it needs to get decent quality, but I don?t see why a little man on a horse or a crocodile makes a shirt any better, and you don?t see any better through Armani glasses. And simplification also applies to language- thanks, #7 (jad67). I?ve been trying to re-ink my dichotomised boundaries, but it goes all over my fingers... and what was wrong with the old black anyway?

    Draw the maximum personal reward from the forthcoming 24-hour life experience - sorry, have a nice day....

  •  
    8

    Peter Cadorna

    08/20/09 | Report as spam

    RE: How to Market in a Downturn

    Hi! I'm Peter Cadorna, From Manila, Phil.

    My response to this Topic is, Either way, Be it a Down Trend or an Up Trend Market, there's always the Opportunity.

    One factor that a Marketing Person should consider is to study the culture of the particular country where the Business is located. The buying behavior normally follows on the culture of a certain Country.

    In the case of the Philippine Culture, The Down Trend Market
    condition doesn't affect for Star Bucks in Manila.

    Let me site you the Filipino Culture. It is Philippine Culture to be friendly, Hospitable, with a kind Heart. You'll noticed in Manila alone, to my observation, 30% of the Market of Start Buck comes from an Ordinary Call Center Employees.

    These people doesn't have much income, But they are proud to relax with their friends after office hours at Start Bucks. The being friendly and hospitable culture of the Filipinos plays an important role in the Business of Star Bucks. People would always like to Treat their friends for a coffee at Star Bucks, not at MC Donald?

    That is the average income people. What about the high income Category? The more that they keep coming back to Star Bucks.

    One more thing, The average income people who have friends from the high income group, are always proud to meet their friend at Star Bucks. Understanding the Culture of a certain Country will give you a niche market.

    Thanks,

    Peter

  •  
    9

    Peter Cadorna

    08/20/09 | Report as spam

    RE: How to Market in a Downturn

    I can be reach here!
    Acme-People-Search.com

  •  
    10

    sunil saraf

    09/22/09 | Report as spam

    RE: How to Market in a Downturn

    A good luxury brand has a memory and is receptive of
    customer's needs, whims and fancies. Luxury brand is a pinnacle
    of solidity in terms of quality and finesse. Therefore does not
    waver in the eyes of super rich. Super luxury brand finds enough evangelists to create an aura around it that insulates it from up
    or downturn. It is like a 'lotus flower' in a pond, blossoming with
    out fear of water sticking to it reducing its shine.

Please add your comment:

  1. You are currently: a Guest |
  2.  

Basic HTML tags that work in comments are: bold (<b></b>), italic (<i></i>), underline (<u></u>), and hyperlink (<a href></a)